Which is best for communion, grape juice or wine?

what does the bible say?

The choice between grape juice and wine for communion is not a matter of spiritual superiority. Communion is meant to be about remembering Christ and His sacrifice, not to debate about what liquid is used (Mark 14:22-25). In biblical times, wine was used during the first communion, largely because refrigeration was unavailable, yet even then, drunkenness was a concern (1 Corinthians 11:17-26; Ephesians 5:18). Today, churches have the freedom to use grape juice, especially to protect those with a history of alcoholism, young attendees, or those with personal convictions against alcohol (Romans 14:21). The focus of communion must always remain on the heart and intent of believers, not the type of beverage served (John 2:1-11; 1 Timothy 5:23). While wine has historical and cultural significance, grape juice is equally valid in helping believers collectively remember Christ’s sacrifice. God is honored not by the drink itself but by the reverence and unity in which communion is taken (Mark 14:24-25).

from the old testament

• Wine was regularly used in feasts, offerings, and celebrations, such as in the Feast of Weeks (Leviticus 23:13) or in drink offerings accompanying sacrifices (Exodus 29:40). Fermented grape products were culturally normal in religious life.
• During the Passover feast, participants drank wine as part of the ceremonial meal (Exodus 12:14-20; Exodus 24:6-8).
• Wine in Passover symbolized the joy of redemption and God’s covenant with Israel. Each cup represented a part of God’s saving work, which is echoed in communion where wine (or juice) represents Christ’s blood (Matthew 26:28).
• Wine often symbolized joy, blessing, and God’s provision (Psalm 104:15; Joel 2:19). This highlights that the purpose is symbolic—representing blessing and covenant—rather than focusing on the exact beverage used.

from the new testament

• The original communion meal existed during a time before refrigeration. Nearly everyone drank wine as grape juice quickly fermented. It is clear that Jesus and His disciples drank wine during the first communion (Mark 14:22-25). Though the tradition simply says “cup,” the problems associated with wine at communion in 1 Corinthians 11:17-26 show that drinking too much of this drink at communion resulted in drunkenness.
• We should act in alignment with our state laws. Many young people take communion in church. In many countries, the age limits for drinking alcohol are 21 or at least 18 years old. Although there may be exemptions for churches, leaders in the church are still wise to consider if using wine would tempt young people to justify disobeying the comm and to “be subject to the governing authorities” (Romans 13:1) when it comes to drinking wine outside of the church building.
• Churches should be aware of believers with a history of alcoholism. Romans 14:21 states, “It is good not to eat meat or drink wine or do anything that causes your brother to stumble.” Since there are likely people in any larger congregation who have struggled with the abuse of alcohol, it may be safer to use juice to avoid causing a problem for those who have concerns in this area. There may also be those who avoid alcohol out of personal preference or even conviction. Providing grape juice instead of wine makes such people less alienated since everyone would be drinking the same thing.
• Church leaders are called to be “above reproach” (1 Timothy 3:2). This includes living with character and avoiding things that could cause sinful accusations to occur in the church as much as possible. Using grape juice instead of wine may help with this concern, since there would not be the temptation to misuse the church’s wine when no one is looking.

implications for today

Wine was the traditional drink used at Passover for the Jewish people. Yet today, many churches and believers have debated what drink should be used during communion (also known as the Lord’s Supper or Eucharist). While the use of wine in communion may not be a problem in some cultures, it clearly can be in others. Each church and its leaders must carefully consider both the biblical information and the cultural impact of their decision and choose what will best build up the body of Christ and help in serving one’s community. God can be honored through either the use of real wine or grape juice. The concern is not with the type of drink but with the remembrance of Christ through the ordinance of communion.

Recap

understand

• Communion’s focus is on remembering Christ, not the drink used.
• Wine was used for Passover but likely because of lack of refrigeration.
• Churches may use grape juice or wine for communion; what is important is the heart in taking communion and what it reflects.

reflect

• How does your heart and attitude during communion reflect your remembrance of Christ’s sacrifice?
• How do you ensure that taking communion is focused on Christ rather than what beverage is used?
• How can you honor unity and sensitivity to others when participating in communion?

engage

• How might a church’s decision to use wine or grape juice influence believers’ view of communion?
• In what ways might focusing on the heart behind communion, rather than the beverage, encourage deeper reflection and unity among believers?
• How can leaders balance cultural, legal, and personal considerations while maintaining the spiritual significance of communion?