Did Jesus lie to His brothers in John 7:8–10?

what does the bible say?

John records that Jesus’ brothers urged Him to go publicly to the Feast of Booths. Jesus replied that His time had not yet come, told them to go, and stayed in Galilee; after they left, He went to the feast privately (John 7:1–10). John also notes the brothers’ unbelief, which helps explain their goading Him to go with them (John 7:5). There was real danger in Judea, where people sought to kill Him (John 7:1–2). Jesus came midway through the feast to teach, fitting a deliberate plan, rather than a reversal or deception (John 7:14). Throughout John’s Gospel, the motif of Jesus’ “hour” controls His actions and public revelations (John 2:4; John 7:30; John 8:20). Some older manuscripts read “not yet” in John 7:8, and several translations reflect this. The context does indicate that He meant He would not go then, or with them. He later went in a way that avoided premature confrontation, consistent with His mission (John 7:10; John 5:19; John 5:30). Scripture affirms Jesus is sinless and the embodiment of truth, which rules out lying (Hebrews 4:15; 1 Peter 2:22; John 14:6). Since God does not lie, and Jesus is the Son of God, deception would contradict His nature (Numbers 23:19; 1 John 5:20).

from the old testament

• This question relates to a moment recorded in the Gospel of John, which is not found in the Old Testament.

from the new testament

• The concern is whether Jesus contradicted Himself when He told His brothers He was not going up to the Feast of Booths and then went later (John 7:8–10). John reminded the readers about the real hostility He would have faced, saying, “He would not go about in Judea, because the Jews were seeking to kill him” (John 7:1).
• John wrote that the brothers, who did not believe in Him (John 7:5), were teasing Him to reveal who He was publicly (John 7:3–4). So, they were not inviting Him—they were mocking Him and, unintentionally, pushing for His likely death if He showed up. Jesus discerns motives (John 2:24–25) and wisely declined their plan.
• The core of this answer lies in how John repeatedly mentioned Jesus’ “hour” not yet arriving (John 2:4; John 8:20). In this exchange, Jesus said, “My time has not yet come, but your time is always here. The world cannot hate you, but it hates me because I testify about it that its works are evil. You go up to the feast. I am not going up to this feast, for my time has not yet fully come” (John 7:6–8). He was indicating that if He went, He would be killed, and it was not yet His time to die.
• Unlike the public way his brothers wanted, Jesus left quietly afterward to arrive secretly (John 7:10). So, Jesus rejected his brothers’ method of revealing Himself and chose a path that aligned with the Father’s will and avoided an early public confrontation.
• A small detail in the text helps clarify the reading. Some older manuscripts include the word “yet” in verse 8, reflected in translations that read, “I am not yet going” (KJV, NKJV). Even though “yet” is not in the primary manuscripts, that is a reasonable deduction based on the context. He was not going then or with His brothers, but He still planned to go His own way.
• Scripture consistently portrays Jesus as divine (i.e., John 1:1) and, therefore, incapable of sinning (Hebrews 4:15; 1 Peter 2:22; 1 John 3:5). As a result, lying would conflict with His nature. John gives no indication of deception during the interaction with Jesus and the brothers. Instead, it seems to be a refusal to give in to unbelieving pressure.

implications for today

Because Jesus always tells the truth, you can trust what He says. Every promise He makes is sure, every warning is real, and every comm and is trustworthy. Unlike people, whose words fail, His are unshakable (Titus 1:2). This means your faith has a strong foundation. When Jesus says He gives eternal life, you can feel secure in that promise (John 10:28). When He promises to return, you can live with hope and readiness (John 14:3). And when He declares Himself as the way, the truth, and the life, you can be confident that only through Him do we find the Father (John 14:6). So, why not lean on Jesus with confidence? In a world full of confusing voices, Jesus remains honest and faithful. Building your life on His words isn’t just safe—it’s life-giving. His integrity guarantees salvation for everyone who believes. Trust in Him and experience the peace and hope that come from a solid, unshakeable foundation.

Recap

understand

• Jesus’ statement “I am not going up” reflected His timing and method, not a denial of going altogether.
• Jesus’ brothers’ unbelief and pressure explain why He rejected their plan for a public appearance.
• Jesus is sinless and the embodiment of truth, so lying would contradict His divine nature.

reflect

• How does knowing Jesus never lies affect your trust in His words and promises?
• In what areas of your life might you be tempted to follow the world’s timing instead of God’s?
• How can you rely on Jesus’ truthfulness when facing pressure or misunderstanding from others?

engage

• Why is understanding Jesus’ “hour” important for interpreting His actions in the Gospels?
• How does Jesus’s response to His brothers model discernment and obedience for us today?
• What can we learn about the tension between human expectation and God’s timing from this passage?